Scotch:
A Malted Barley Masterpiece
Mash Bill: Scotch whisky is traditionally made from 100% malted barley.
This gives it a distinctive depth of flavor and complexity. Unlike other whisky styles, Scotch’s reliance on malted barley contributes to its rich, cereal-like sweetness with underlying notes of nuttiness, earthiness, or even floral and citrus hints, depending on the region.
Variations:
Single Malt Scotch is crafted at a single distillery using only malted barley and pot stills, resulting in a spirit that reflects both the grain’s natural character and the craftsmanship of the distiller.
Blended Scotch combines multiple single malts with grain whisky (which may include wheat or corn-based spirits) to create a balanced, accessible flavor profile.
Peated vs. Unpeated Malts: Some distilleries dry their malted barley over peat fires, infusing the grain with smoky, medicinal, or maritime flavors that carry through to the finished whisky.
Because Scotch law prohibits additives beyond water and caramel coloring, the entire flavor profile of Scotch comes from the grain, fermentation, distillation, and maturation. The emphasis on malted barley, along with traditional distillation methods, ensures Scotch whisky retains its signature depth, mouthfeel, and complexity.
How the Grain Bill Shapes Flavor
The ingredients used in Scotch and Bourbon impact not only flavor but also mouthfeel, texture, and aroma.
Scotch’s malted barley produces a layered, sometimes dry or nutty complexity, with flavors ranging from honey and fruit to smoke and spice, depending on the region and barrel aging.
Bourbon’s corn-heavy profile ensures a bolder, rounder sweetness with rich vanilla, caramel, and oak-driven spice, enhanced by new charred oak barrels.
Rye-heavy mash bills (in bourbon or rye whiskey) contribute sharp, peppery heat, while wheat softens and rounds out the profile.
Bourbon:
The Sweet Influence of Corn
Mash Bill: Bourbon’s defining characteristic is its high corn content—by law, it must be made from at least 51% corn.
This gives bourbon a natural sweetness, often described as caramel, toffee, or honey-like.
Variations:
High-Corn Bourbons (60-80% corn) tend to be smoother and sweeter, with pronounced vanilla and butterscotch notes due to the interplay between corn’s sugars and the new charred oak barrels used for aging.
Rye-Forward Bourbons contain a significant portion of rye grain in addition to corn (usually 10-30%), adding a spicier, bolder kickwith notes of black pepper, cinnamon, and baking spices.
Wheated Bourbons substitute rye for wheat in the mash bill, resulting in a softer, creamier mouthfeel with gentle, mellow sweetness.
Bourbon’s grain bill often includes smaller amounts of malted barley (usually around 5-12%) to aid in fermentation, as barley naturally contains enzymes that help convert starches to fermentable sugars.
Summary
This careful selection of grains is why Scotch tends to be lighter and more nuanced, whereas Bourbon is often fuller-bodied and sweeter with pronounced wood influence. The grain bill sets the stage for everything that follows—from fermentation to distillation and aging—making it one of the most critical choices in whisky-making.
Want more whisky wisdom?
Follow us on Instagram for exclusive behind-the-scenes looks, tastings, and cocktail inspiration.
Join Us for 10% off!
Sign up for distillery updates, cocktail recipes, guided tastings, and receive 10% off your first online purchase!
